We need to talk about something. Because twenty years ago a man in a hockey mask and a friendly smile sat down with a documentary crew, explained with great patience and enthusiasm exactly how he planned to murder a group of teenagers, and somehow became one of the most lovable characters in horror history. And now he’s coming back.
Behind the Mask II: The Return of Leslie Vernon is officially happening. The announcement dropped yesterday and our group chats have not recovered.
Wait, Back Up. What Even Is Behind the Mask?
If you’ve somehow not seen the original, first of all, what are you doing, go watch it. Right now. We’ll wait. Back? Good. For the uninitiated, Behind the Mask: The Rise of Leslie Vernon came out in 2006, directed by Scott Glosserman, and it is a mockumentary following an aspiring serial killer named Leslie Vernon as he prepares for his first big killing spree. He walks a documentary crew through every step. The cardio. The victim selection. The survivor girl. The layout of the farmhouse he’s rigged to work in his favor. The man explains slasher movie logic from the inside with the cheerful professionalism of someone walking you through their home renovation project.
It is, as we has called it before, it is “a meta-horror masterpiece.” It holds a 76% on Rotten Tomatoes and a devoted cult following that has spent twenty years demanding a sequel and getting absolutely nothing for their trouble. Until now.
So What Do We Actually Know?
Variety broke the news that the sequel is officially underway, with director Scott Glosserman and writer David J. Stieve both returning alongside the original cast. Nathan Baesel is back as Leslie. Angela Goethals is back as Taylor, the journalist who followed him around with a camera while he planned murders, which remains a bold career choice on her part. And Robert Englund is back as Doc Halloran, the psychiatrist on Leslie’s trail, which means we get Robert Englund in a Behind the Mask movie again and we are choosing to not take that for granted.
The film is being produced by Paper Street Pictures, the genre company led by Aaron B. Koontz and Cameron Burns. Adam F. Goldberg, the creator of The Goldbergs and director of Shelby Oaks, is joining as executive producer. A Kickstarter is also launching alongside the announcement, not because the film depends on it, but because Glosserman wants the audience in on the process.
“We’re making the movie either way. But the more the audience gets involved, the bigger we can make it. Bigger set pieces. More cameos. More surprises. This has always been a fan-driven film, and it still is.”Scott Glosserman, via Variety
More cameos. In a Behind the Mask movie. The original had Robert Englund and Kane Hodder. The sequel, if we fund it properly, apparently gets to go bigger than that. We are choosing to interpret this as a personal challenge.
Why Now? Why Did It Take Twenty Years?
This is the part of the story that reads like a horror movie itself, minus the blood, plus a lot of Hollywood phone calls that went nowhere. Glosserman and Stieve have been trying to get a sequel made since roughly 2007. Multiple versions of the script. Multiple attempts at crowdfunding. Years of the sand shifting under them, as Stieve put it to Den of Geek in an interview this week.
The problem, as Glosserman explained it, was the genre kept changing around them. Torture porn. Found footage. J-horror. Remakes. Reboots. Every time they had a version of the sequel ready, the horror landscape had moved on and the self-referential angle they needed to lean into felt like it was chasing something. Stieve described it as trying to keep pace with the genre while the ground kept moving underneath them. They tried and tried and couldn’t quite land it.
What changed? Two things, really. The first is that the meta-slasher is back in a big way. Scream never went away. Scary Movie is literally getting another sequel this year. The genre is deep in its own mythology again, which is exactly the kind of water Leslie Vernon was built to swim in. The second is that the filmmakers finally found the right angle, one that uses the twenty years of failure as the story itself.
“The sequel will not only reflect the conventions and archetypes of horror, but also our own lived experience.”Scott Glosserman, via Den of Geek
And Nathan Baesel, who has carried Leslie Vernon as a character in his head for two decades now, told the AV Club at the 20th anniversary screening in Los Angeles where the announcement was first made: “Leslie is not just here because he’s got an opportunity here, because he is going to change the world, right? He’s not just looking to have another story this time around. He’s looking to change the game.”
A slasher villain who never quite made the big leagues, returning twenty years later with something to prove. That is either the most Behind the Mask premise imaginable, or it’s just true. Probably both.
Robert Englund, Again, in This Role, in 2026
We want to give this its own section because it deserves one. Robert Englund is 78 years old. He has said publicly and repeatedly that he is done playing Freddy Krueger, which is a decision we respect even as it breaks our collective heart a little. He still works constantly, still shows up for horror in ways that remind you why we love him so much, we covered when his documentary came to Screambox. Doc Halloran is not Freddy, but he is an Englund role in a horror film that deserves him, and the fact that he’s back for this sequel feels significant in a way we’re not going to oversell but are definitely going to feel.
Here’s the thing about this franchise that makes the sequel feel like more than just good news. The original Behind the Mask barely got a theatrical release. It went to DVD and then it traveled. Fan to fan. Convention to convention. Late-night screening to late-night screening. It is the exact kind of horror film that exists entirely because the people who loved it refused to let it disappear.
As we noted earlier this year when covering a new meta found footage film, the genre hadn’t seen anything quite like Behind the Mask in a long time, a film that could pull off the trick of living fully inside slasher logic while simultaneously being smarter than it. That gap has been twenty years wide. And the people who kept the original alive didn’t do it through algorithm or marketing. They did it the way horror communities actually work, by caring loudly and specifically and not shutting up about it until someone listened.
Glosserman said it directly in his statement: “Fans kept this movie alive by sharing it, quoting it, introducing it to their friends, and treating it like something worth holding onto. This sequel is happening because of them.”
We are them. Hi.
When and How Do We See It
No release date has been announced yet. The Kickstarter campaign is expected to launch alongside the announcement, with stretch goals tied to cast reveals for additional cameos. What we know is that the full original creative team is back, filming is moving forward, and writer David J. Stieve told Den of Geek simply: “If we miss this window, what are we doing out here?”
That feels right. The window is open. The meta-slasher is alive again. And somewhere in a farmhouse that’s been rigged specifically against you, Leslie Vernon is warming up, reviewing his cardio numbers, and getting ready to change the game.
We have been waiting twenty years for this. We would like it noted for the record that we held it together pretty well.